The greatest threat to the life of gastrinoma patients is not the complications of ulcers but the invasion of malignant tumors. The treatment goal for gastrinoma patients is to control ulcers, prevent complications, and control tumor progression.
1. Treatment of gastrinoma
Before effective acid-suppressing treatment appears, the main cause of death in gastrinoma patients is peptic ulcers and their complications. Total gastrectomy is the only effective solution. The introduction of H2 receptor blockers and proton pump inhibitors has greatly reduced the incidence and mortality rates of the syndrome with peptic ulcers, effectively avoiding total gastrectomy. Now, the greatest threat to the life of gastrinoma patients is not the complications of ulcers but the invasion of malignant tumors. Data show that more than 50% of gastrinoma patients who have not undergone surgical resection die of direct invasion by the tumor. The treatment goal for gastrinoma patients is to control ulcers, prevent complications, and control tumor progression.
1. Medical treatment:The main objective of medical treatment for gastrinoma patients is to alleviate clinical symptoms, inhibit gastric acid secretion, and prevent peptic ulcers, with the basis of treatment being the use of acid-suppressing drugs. All gastrinoma patients should periodically titrate gastric acid concentration to determine the dosage of acid-suppressing drugs, aiming to reduce gastric acid secretion to less than 10 mmol/h before the next dose.
It has been reported that two special subgroups of gastrinoma patients (patients with partial gastrectomy and those with gastrinoma complicated with moderate or severe gastroesophageal acid reflux) need to be more actively treated to reduce gastric acid secretion than other gastrinoma patients, and maintain it at
(1) Proton pump inhibitors: Proton pump inhibitors such as omeprazole, lansoprazole, pantoprazole, rabeprazole, and esomeprazole effectively inhibit gastric acid secretion by irreversibly binding to the H-KATPase of parietal cells, with an effect that can last for more than 24 hours, and many patients can be administered once daily.
Gastrinoma patients can start treatment with omeprazole 60mg once daily, lansoprazole 45mg once daily, or rabeprazole 60mg once daily. Some patients may require higher doses at the beginning of treatment, but once the gastric acid secretion is controlled, the dosage of the drug can usually be gradually reduced. For example, a study included 37 gastrinoma patients using high-dose omeprazole, and the research found that nearly 50% of the patients could reduce the maintenance dose to 20mg once daily over the past two years. In summary, 95% of patients with MEN-I syndrome, severe gastroesophageal reflux disease, or a history of partial gastrectomy can safely reduce the dosage of the drug. Before reducing the dosage of the drug, the gastric acid secretion should be measured for 2 weeks for each patient. If symptoms recur or the gastric acid secretion is greater than 10mmol/h before the next dose, the original dose must be restored.
(2) H2 receptor antagonists: The advent of H2 receptor antagonists has made it possible for the medical treatment of gastrinoma patients. H2 receptor antagonists can alleviate symptoms, reduce acid secretion, and cure ulcers. Cimetidine is the first H2 receptor antagonist proven to be effective, which can cure 80% to 85% of the ulcers in gastrinoma patients, and ranitidine and famotidine are also effective. The dosage of H2 receptor antagonists used in the treatment of this disease is much higher than that of common duodenal ulcers. To reduce the patient's gastric acid secretion to a satisfactory level (less than 10mmol/h), the average daily dosage of H2 receptor antagonists is: cimetidine 7.8g (1.2-13.2g), ranitidine 2.1g (0.6-3.6g), and famotidine 0.24g (0.08-0.48g). H2 receptor antagonists have no effect on serum gastrin levels and the biological behavior of gastrinomas. It is not uncommon for gastrinoma patients to be sensitive to H2 receptor antagonist treatment at the beginning and then develop resistance. After long-term treatment observation, it was found that 50% of the patients failed to respond to H2 receptor antagonist treatment, and there was no significant correlation between symptom control and ulcer cure or recurrence after H2 receptor antagonist treatment. Therefore, some scholars suggest that the dosage of H2 receptor antagonists or other acid-suppressing agents should be adjusted to ensure that the gastric acid secretion is less than 10mmol/h before the next acid-suppressing agent is taken. The combination of H2 receptor antagonists with anticholinergic drugs can enhance the efficacy of H2 receptor antagonists in reducing gastric acid secretion.
(3) Octreotide: By directly inhibiting the release of parietal cells and gastrin, octreotide reduces gastric acid secretion. Natural octreotide is limited in its application due to its short half-life. The synthetic octreotide analog has a half-life of 2 hours and can be administered subcutaneously. It can reduce serum gastrin concentration for 16 hours and reduce gastric acid secretion for 18 hours. Its long-term application is not superior to omeprazole, but it can be used for acid-suppressing treatment in gastrinoma patients who need parenteral administration for a short period of time.
2. Surgical Treatment:Surgical resection of gastrinoma is the best treatment for gastrinoma patients, with the goal of completely resecting the tumor to eliminate high gastrin secretion, high gastric acid secretion, and peptic ulcers, and protecting patients from the invasion of malignant tumors. A careful localization and assessment of the gastrinoma should be made before surgery, and except for patients with contraindications to surgery, those who refuse surgery, and those with multiple liver metastases who are unable to undergo surgery, all other patients should undergo surgical treatment.
If no metastatic focus is found during surgical exploration or if metastasis is limited to lymph nodes, the possibility that the patient will die from tumor metastasis is not high. Liver metastasis is a sign of poor prognosis, with nearly 20% to 30% of patients having liver metastasis at the time of diagnosis, and 15% of these patients have metastasis limited to one lobe. Some believe that aggressive resection of intraperitoneal metastatic foci is beneficial clinically, and if the metastatic gastrinoma is limited to one lobe of the liver, complete resection is considered safe and feasible. Patients with liver-limited metastases can also undergo liver transplantation, but whether it improves survival rates is still uncertain. There are also reports of solitary primary gastrinomas originating in the liver, which are cured by complete resection of the liver tumor. There has been controversy about the surgical treatment of gastrinoma patients with MEN-Ⅰ, with some believing that patients with MEN-Ⅰ should not undergo surgery because these tumors are polymorphic and multicentric. After resection of the gastrinoma, neither a cure nor the normalization of serum gastrin levels can be achieved.
3. Other Surgery:The general view is that patients with hyperparathyroidism in MEN-Ⅰ should first undergo parathyroidectomy. For patients with gastrinoma, partial gastrectomy is not considered, and patients who have undergone total gastrectomy for gastrinoma should be injected intramuscularly with vitamin B12 and early oral calcium and vitamin D every month to prevent osteoporosis and osteomalacia. Performing a vagotomy of the proximal stomach at the same time as tumor resection can allow patients to avoid postoperative medication, which is particularly valuable for those who have completely removed the tumor but still cannot solve the problem of high gastric acid secretion. Most scholars believe that in exploratory surgery, vagotomy of the proximal stomach should be performed in all patients. Observations of 124 patients who had no tumor metastasis found in imaging examinations and underwent surgical treatment showed a decrease in mortality rate. Among the 98 patients followed up for 6.3 years after tumor resection, only 3% showed liver metastasis, whereas, among the 26 patients treated medically over an 8.7-year follow-up period, 23% had tumor metastasis. Two patients in the medical treatment group died of metastatic gastrinoma, while no patient in the surgical group died directly from the tumor.
Gastric acid secretion may not necessarily return to normal after resection of the gastrinoma, which may be due to the nutritional effects of the long-term elevated gastrin before surgery and the excessive gastrin remaining after surgery on the gastric mucosal cells. nearly 40% of patients still need to extend the acid-suppressing drug treatment to control the increased gastric acid secretion after surgery, and these patients also need to monitor the gastric acid secretion.
Gastrinoma patients who have undergone complete tumor resection usually have their serum gastrin levels immediately drop to normal, gastric acid secretion decreases, ulcers heal, diarrhea disappears, and survival rates are close to those of normal people. Nearly 40% of gastrinoma patients can have their tumors completely resected. Long-term omeprazole treatment for patients who cannot be resected can also reduce gastric acid secretion, alleviate symptoms of ulcers and diarrhea, and promote ulcer healing. One should not discontinue or reduce the dose of omeprazole when long-term treatment has begun, as this may have the potential to cause tumor infiltration and lead to recurrence after discontinuation.
Patients who cannot be surgically resected for gastrinoma and have undergone proximal gastric vagotomy may be able to reduce the dose of omeprazole. Gastrinoma patients who have undergone total gastrectomy may have improved symptoms, disappearance of ulcers, but the serum gastrin concentration of most patients does not change, only about 1/3 may have a moderate decrease in serum gastrin levels, which may be due to the resection of the gastrinoma located in the first part of the duodenum during total gastrectomy.
The treatment of gastrinoma patients is a lifelong process. Although the course and monitoring of each patient have individual differences, some programmed monitoring methods are introduced below: After clear resection of gastrinoma, routine evaluation should be carried out annually, including medical history and physical examination, fasting serum gastrin and gastric acid secretion determination, and secretin stimulation test. If there is progressive increase in fasting gastrin levels, one should be vigilant for tumor recurrence. If the fasting serum gastrin level is normal in the first year after surgical resection of the tumor, then 95% of the patients will have normal fasting serum gastrin levels after 3 years. In the cases of gastrinoma patients who seem to have been successfully resected, the secretin stimulation test is considered the best detection method, and regular imaging examinations are not necessary unless the fasting serum gastrin level increases or the secretin stimulation test is positive. For patients who have not found or resected or only partially resected gastrinoma, the monitoring methods are the same as before, and these patients should also measure the gastric acid secretion rate before the next dose to determine the dosage. In addition, regular evaluations should be carried out for gastrinoma patients who have not localized the tumor, including imaging examinations every 2 to 3 years to find the tumor and perform surgical resection.
4. Reoperation:Although surgery reduces the incidence and mortality rate of tumor metastasis, less than 30% of patients can achieve long-term biological cure. For those patients with recurrent gastrinoma that can be detected by imaging, reoperation may be beneficial. For example, in 17 patients with gastrinoma confirmed by imaging, 5 patients were able to survive without disease for a median follow-up period of 28 months, and there were no deaths in the reoperation cure group.
5. Treatment for patients with tumor metastasis:The liver is the most common site of gastrinoma metastasis. A study group used various imaging methods to detect it, and found that 7% of all patients had bone metastasis, 31% had liver metastasis, but all patients with bone metastasis had liver metastasis. Bone metastasis mainly affects the axial skeleton (such as the spine and sacrum), but can also affect other parts of the skeleton. Octreotide (Sandostatin) receptor scanning and MRI are the best methods to detect these lesions, the former is better in detecting bone metastases outside the axial skeleton. Gastrinoma metastasis occurs frequently in gastrinoma patients and is the most common cause of death, and there is still no effective treatment method to date.
6. Chemotherapy:There are different chemotherapy regimens for malignant gastrinoma, including streptozocin (streptozotocin), streptozocin plus 5-fluorouracil, or both combined with doxorubicin. In an experiment involving patients with insulinoma, the combination of streptozocin and doxorubicin was effective in 69% of patients and significantly improved survival rates. However, in the retrospective analysis of different patient groups later, there is no evidence to show that it has such a good effect. There are few studies evaluating the efficacy of systemic chemotherapy in gastrinoma patients. In a single-center study report, 10 gastrinoma patients received combined treatment with 5-fluorouracil, doxorubicin, and streptozocin, and 4 patients achieved the expected goal (tumor shrinkage of 25%), but the median effective period did not exceed 10 months. Considering these uncertain results and the side effects of chemotherapy such as bone marrow suppression and gastrointestinal symptoms, the benefits and risks should be carefully weighed before chemotherapy. There are reports suggesting that interferon alpha is effective for gastrointestinal neuroendocrine tumors including gastrinoma, and can keep 20% to 40% of patients in a stable state, but its widespread application is limited by its side effects such as influenza-like symptoms, fatigue, and depression.
Some scholars advocate early chemotherapy, while more scholars believe that chemotherapy should only be recommended when symptoms caused by tumor masses or organ erosion occur (the liver is always involved almost). No chemotherapy for those who are only involved by lymph nodes. Chemotherapy cannot reduce gastric acid secretion, but it has certain effects on reducing tumor volume and alleviating symptoms caused by tumor masses or infiltration. Chemotherapy cannot improve survival rates, and it is currently believed that interferon can cause tumor growth to stop in 25% of patients with metastatic gastrinoma, but it cannot reduce tumor volume or improve survival rates.
There are also reports suggesting that long-acting somatostatin analogs can alleviate symptoms caused by tumor activity function and slow down tumor growth in patients with malignant gastrointestinal neuroendocrine tumors, but imaging examination did not find tumor shrinkage after treatment.
7. Hepatic artery embolization method:Hepatic artery embolization can be used as a palliative therapy for liver metastasis of insulinoma, which has more than half of the effective rate in reducing hormone secretion or tumor shrinkage under imaging. However, its efficacy is short-lived, and its possible side effects, including pain, gastrointestinal reactions, and liver function abnormalities, limit its use.
8. Treatment of gastrinoma patients:General guidelines for the selection of proton pump inhibitors, which can effectively inhibit gastric acid secretion, facilitate the healing of ulcers in patients with gastrinoma, can be used during the stage of disease evaluation and before surgery; they should also be used for patients who are unable to undergo surgery or whose tumor lesions cannot be found. Stable patients require intravenous acid-suppressing drugs during disease evaluation and preoperative preparation. After careful evaluation and localization, surgery aimed at tumor resection should be performed for each patient with gastrinoma, unless the patient has clearly stated that surgery is not possible (such as when liver metastasis exceeds one lobe) or the patient refuses surgery or has contraindications to surgery. During surgery, the tumor should be identified and completely removed, and all lymph nodes involved by the tumor should also be removed. If it is safe and possible to completely remove the metastatic lesions, the liver metastatic lesions should also be removed; there is no need for a total gastrectomy. As for whether there is a need for surgery in patients with gastrinoma complicated with MEN-Ⅰ syndrome, there is still controversy. However, the improved success rate of surgery now suggests the value of tumor resection. For all first-degree relatives of patients with MEN-Ⅰ syndrome, the possibility of tumor should be considered, and it is advisable to detect fasting gastrin and perform secretin stimulation tests in this group to exclude potential tumor possibilities. For patients with a clear diagnosis of gastrinoma but who, despite maximum efforts, cannot locate and remove the tumor, both patients and doctors face several treatment options. The most cautious method is lifelong acid-suppressing drug therapy (such as omeprazole). For patients who cannot or do not want to accept lifelong drug treatment and it is impossible to completely remove the gastrinoma, consider total gastrectomy or proximal vagotomy, but it may still be necessary to take a small amount of acid-suppressing drugs for a long time after surgery.
Second,GastrinomaPrognosis
The application of general acid-suppressing and anticholinergic drugs in this disease can only achieve temporary efficacy, and it is difficult to be completely cured. According to literature reports, about half of the death causes of patients treated without surgery are complications of peptic ulcer disease rather than death from malignant tumors.
The mortality rate of total gastrectomy as an elective surgery is about 5%, and as an emergency surgery, it can reach as high as 50%, generally around 20%. The one-year survival rate of patients after total gastrectomy is 75%, the five-year survival rate is 55%, and the ten-year survival rate is 42%. About half of the deceased patients die of tumors. Some people believe that total gastrectomy may inhibit tumor growth and extend the life of patients. Among a group of 243 cases with proven metastatic tumors, 66% had long-term survival after total gastrectomy, while those who did not undergo total gastrectomy were only 32%. Some people also believe that total gastrectomy has no significant inhibitory effect on tumor growth, and treatment with drugs such as streptozocin or 5-FU is still needed after the operation.